Would Have Been, Had There Been One at the Time
1904 Jack Chesbro
1921 Carl Mays
1922 Joe Bush
1923 Sam Jones
1927 Waite Hoyt
1928 Waite Hoyt
1932 Lefty Gomez
1934 Lefty Gomez
1937 Lefty Gomez
1938 Red Ruffing
1939 Red Ruffing
1942 Tiny Bonham
1943 Spud Chandler
1949 Vic Raschi
1950 Vic Raschi
1951 Eddie Lopat
1953 Allie Reynolds
1958 Bob Turley
1961 Whitey Ford
1962 Ralph Terry
1963 Whitey Ford
Did Win
1977 Sparky Lyle (1st AL relief pitcher to win it)
1978 Ron Guidry
2001 Roger Clemens
Should Have Won
1996 Andy Pettitte (Pat Hentgen won it)
1998 David Wells (Roger Clemens with Toronto)
1999 Mariano Rivera (Pedro Martinez)
2003 Mariano Rivera (Roy Halladay)
2006 Chien-Ming Wang (Johan Santana)
2009 CC Sabathia (Zack Greinke)
Will Win
2023 Gerrit Cole